
Quick answer: Sciatica usually keeps coming back because the cause of the nerve irritation was never fully treated. The most common causes are a herniated or torn disc, narrowing of the space around the nerve (spinal stenosis), and a vertebra that has slipped forward (spondylolisthesis). Rest and medication can calm a flare, but if the pressure on the nerve remains, the pain tends to return.
What is sciatica?
Sciatica is a symptom, not a diagnosis. It describes pain that runs from the lower back or buttock down the back of the leg, along the path of the sciatic nerve. It can feel sharp, burning or electric, and it often comes with numbness or tingling. The real question is what’s irritating the nerve.
Common causes of recurring sciatica
Herniated disc. The most common cause. Even after a flare settles, the disc can still be close to the nerve, and a re-herniation at the same level can bring symptoms back.
Annular tears. Tears in the disc’s tough outer wall can leak inflammatory material that irritates nearby nerves, causing pain that comes and goes.
Lumbar spinal stenosis. Narrowing of the spinal canal or the openings where nerves exit. It often causes leg pain that builds with standing or walking and eases when you sit or lean forward.
Spondylolisthesis. A vertebra slips forward over the one below it and narrows the space for the nerve. Learn more about lumbar spondylolisthesis.
Degenerative disc disease. Discs lose height and hydration with age, which can narrow nerve openings over time.
Daily habits. Long hours of sitting, repeated bending and lifting, and weak core muscles don’t usually cause sciatica on their own, but they can keep setting off a nerve that is already irritated.
Does leg pain always mean sciatica?
No. Hip arthritis, a pinched nerve in the buttock (piriformis syndrome), nerve damage from diabetes (peripheral neuropathy) and poor circulation in the legs can all cause leg pain that feels similar. Getting the source right matters, because the treatments are different. A spine specialist can tell them apart with an exam and, when needed, imaging or nerve testing.
Why treating only the symptoms may not be enough
Pain medication, rest and even injections can make a flare bearable, and they have a real place in care. But they don’t change what is pressing on or irritating the nerve. If you’ve had several rounds of sciatica in a year, or each episode lasts longer than the last, it is worth finding out why.
How does a spine specialist evaluate recurring sciatica?
- A detailed history of each episode: what set it off, how long it lasted, what helped
- A neurological exam of strength, reflexes and sensation in both legs
- A review of MRI findings, matched against where you actually feel symptoms
- Nerve testing (EMG) in some cases, to confirm which nerve is involved
When does recurring sciatica need prompt attention?
See a doctor soon if sciatica comes with leg weakness, a foot that drags, or numbness that is spreading. Go to the emergency room for loss of bladder or bowel control or numbness in the groin.
Treatment options for recurring sciatica
Treatment depends on the cause. It may include targeted physical therapy, injections, the non-surgical Discseel® procedure for certain disc-related cases, or, when non-surgical care hasn’t worked and the cause is clear, a decompression surgery that frees the nerve. Dr. Morrison views surgery as a last resort and walks through every option first.
Frequently asked questions
Can sciatica go away permanently?
For many people, yes, especially when the cause is identified and treated. Some people have occasional flares over the years, which is why finding the source matters.
Why does my sciatica get worse when I sit?
Sitting puts more pressure on the lower discs than standing does, which can irritate a nerve that’s already inflamed. Getting up to move every 30 to 45 minutes often helps.
How do I know if my sciatica is coming from a disc?
Disc-related sciatica often gets worse with sitting, bending, coughing or sneezing. An exam and an MRI that matches your symptoms are the best way to know.
Next step: If sciatica keeps returning, request an evaluation or call (561) 284-8455.
This article is for general education and isn’t a substitute for medical advice. Medically reviewed by Dr. John F. Morrison, MD, FAANS.